Top Ten Tuesday: My Contrary Character-Related Feelings

This week’s TTT (hosted by The Broke and the Bookish) has been causing me some serious problems (of the first world variety, obviously). I don’t know why it is so difficult for me to think of characters I like who other people don’t, or characters other people like but I don’t. As one of the most contrary people I know, it shouldn’t be that hard for me to do this.

But it is.

I have, however, finally come up with a list. Phew. What would the world do without me and my lists?

Having given this a disproportionate amount of thought, I’ve realised the characters  for whom I have strong feelings of not-liking-ness can be arranged neatly into categories, which correspond to current popular archetypes in YA.

A Gathering of Shadows FinalThe Tormented PrinceThrone_of_Glass_UK
Despite my epic love of fantasy, I am pretty bored of reading about young men who have been brought up with every privilege imaginable, who somehow still manage to be really unhappy and, frankly, boring. On my hit-list here are some characters who, I believe, are quite popular; Dorian from Throne of Glass, Tamlin from A Court of Thorns and Roses, Cal from Red Queen and Merek from The Sin Eater’s Daughter. I find Dorian’s popularity particularly baffling; I’ve read quite a few reviews and comments in which people express a strong preference for Dorian over Chaol which I literally have no comprehension of whatsoever. I am all for fun-loving princes in the style of Rhy from A Darker Shade of Magic/A Gathering of Shadows. If you’re rich and hot and powerful, bloody enjoy it.

The Manic Pixie Girl (or Boy)
Oh my god, if I am sick of anything in my life it is Manic Pixie Girls. I don’t care what John Green says: there is literally NO WAY AT ALL that real-life teenage boys would find a manic pixie girl appealing. They would run away. Not after the pixie girl, but a million miles in the opposite direction. In this category, obviously, I’m placing Alaska from Looking for Alaska, Zelda from Thanks for the Trouble and bloody Margo from Paper Towns, who is possibly the most annoying character in the whole history of literature (obviously, this is not true. Anna Karenina is the most annoying character in the history of literature). Despite the gender-bending nature of the inclusion of a Manic Pixie Boy in Fans of the Impossible Life in the form of Sebby, he annoyed me as well. There is nothing romantic about people who are fundamentally unreliable. It is time authors stopped lying to teenagers about this.

The Evil Queen
At present, I still quite like this trope, because there’s something comic about the acotarridiculous hyperbole of all the psychotic queens in YA fantasy; I’m putting it in this TTT because I think most readers dislike these characters, while I find them weirdly entertaining. There is, however, probably a limit to my tolerance for reading the same character in every fantasy series, so I am hereby issuing a warning to all authors to think of something new. On my Evil Queens list are Amarantha from A Court of Thorns and Roses, Elara from Red Queen and whatever her name was in The Sin Eater’s Daughter, whose incestuous plotting crossed the line from comic into creepy.

Look at that, I came up with 11! Who knew I was actually such a powerhouse of contrary character-related feeling?



6 thoughts on “Top Ten Tuesday: My Contrary Character-Related Feelings

  1. imyril says:

    I am absolutely with you on the tormented prince and the manic pixie (with a couple of exceptions: I totally warmed to Kizzy in The Long Way to a Small Angry Planet). I have a soft spot for a good villain (my take on this week’s TTT), but I don’t read a lot of YA so the evil queen trope hasn’t totally paled on me yet 🙂 It sounds like those ladies would fail my villain test – solid motivation and bad without being Outrageously Evil In Case You Missed It.


  2. Reg | She Latitude says:

    Haha, I’ve read Rowan and Chaol featured in many of this week’s list but yours is the first I’ve stumbled upon that mentions Dorian! I’m alright about him, but I agree that he’s pretty unhappy and not so exciting. 😛

    John Green is so guilty of the whole manic pixie dream girl trope, I think. But then again I’ve never really connected with his characters.


  3. Bookenstein says:

    I love the little spin you put on this week’s topic. I am 100% in agreement with you on the tormented prince characters. They’re just way overdone; and, quite frankly, make me want to cry from boredom. [/unceremoniously drops Gansey from The Raven Cycle in with that bunch and walks away]

    My TTT


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s